A statutory regulator like SEBI cannot be asked to take as “gospel truth” something published in media, the Supreme Court observed on Friday while hearing arguments on the pleas concerning the Adani-Hindenburg row.
A bench headed by Chief Justice DY Chandrachud asked advocate Prashant Bhushan, who was representing one of the petitioners and was referring to Hindenburg report as well as some reports by the media and the Organised Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP), should the SEBI be following up journalists.
“Therefore, should SEBI be following up journalists and ask a journalist, who is not subject to their jurisdiction, to disclose the underlying material,” said the bench, also comprising justices J B Pardiwala and Manoj Misra.
“I don't think you can ask a statutory regulator to take as a gospel truth something which is filed in a newspaper, whether in the Guardian or the Financial Times.
We have no reason to discredit them (SEBI)…,” the CJI observed.
Bhushan said if a journalist can get hold of the documents, how the SEBI, with all its vast powers of investigation, was not able to get hold of these materials.
“There is a growing tendency of planting stories outside India to influence things and policies inside India,” Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the SEBI, said.
The apex court reserved its order on the pleas concerning the Adani-Hindenburg row on allegations of stock price manipulation. During the hearing, Bhushan said there were many factual revelations made in the Hindenburg report.
“We don't have to treat what is set out in the Hindenburg report as ipso facto a true state of affair,” the bench said, adding that was why it had asked the SEBI to investigate the matter.
“Therefore, we asked SEBI that you go an exercise your powers and test what has now come to light. You treat these as revelations or disclosure of allegations and you now exercise your jurisdiction as an adjudicating body,” it said.
When Bhushan said several credible information were there in the Hindenburg report, the bench observed, “As a court, how do we treat it as credible? We will have to rely on our investigative agencies to investigate it”.
“We can't make that assumption that it is either credible or lacking in credibility,” it said.
The bench observed it has no reason to “discredit” SEBI, which probed allegations against the Adani group, as there was no material before it to doubt what the market regulator has done.
At the outset, Mehta apprised the bench that investigation in 22 out of the 24 cases relating to allegations against the Adani group were over.
“For remaining two, we need information from foreign regulators etc. and some other information. We have been in consultation with them. Some information has come but that is where we are not in control of the time limit for obvious reasons…,” he said.
The bench also heard submissions of advocates representing other petitioners.
A Supreme Court-appointed expert committee had in an interim report in May stated that it saw “no evident pattern of manipulation” in billionaire Gautam Adani's companies and there was no regulatory failure.
It, however, cited several amendments the SEBI made between 2014 and 2019 that constrained the regulator's ability to investigate, and its probe into alleged violations in money flows from offshore entities has “drawn a blank”.
The Adani Group's stocks had been bludgeoned on the bourses after Hindenburg Research made a litany of allegations, including those about fraudulent transactions and share-price manipulation, against the business conglomerate. The Adani Group dismissed the charges as lies, saying it complies with all laws and disclosure requirements.
ALSO READ | India's forex reserve surges by $5.08 billion to rise 11-week high at $595.40 billion
Latest Business News
Top News
DGCA issues circular over reports of planes losing GPS signal over Middle-East
‘Get a room’: Kamya Panjabi slams Isha Malviya-Samarth Jurel for getting cozy in Bigg Boss 17
India TV Sports Wrap on November 25: Today’s top 10 trending news stories
Related Business News
India’s forex reserve surges by $5.08 billion to rise 11-week high at $595.40 billion
Maruti to issue over 1.23 crore shares on preferential basis to SMC for Suzuki Motor Gujarat buyout
Stock markets update: Sensex surges around 68 points, Nifty up by 29 points to 19,830 in early trade
Sensex, Nifty experience flat closure amidst volatility, lack of immediate triggers
FM Nirmala Sitharaman stresses on building awareness among people to curb cyber fraud
Latest News
DDA Housing Scheme 2023: Registration for 32,000 flats commences, step-by-step guide on how to apply
China allows visa-free entry to THESE travelers | 5 points
‘Get a room’: Kamya Panjabi slams Isha Malviya-Samarth Jurel for getting cozy in Bigg Boss 17
This new WhatsApp feature will show your profile information in chats – Deets here
© 2009-2023 Independent News Service. All rights reserved.
Watch Yoga With Swami Ramdev
Aaj Ka Rashifal: Shubh Muhurat | Today Bhavishyavani with Acharya Indu Prakash, Nov 19, 2023
‘Congress Ki Bidaai Ka Waqt…’: PM Modi Predicts Baghel Government’s Defeat In Chhattisgarh
What PM Modi Predicts On Assembly Elections?
PM Modi addresses a public meeting at Chhattisgarh
DGCA issues circular over reports of planes losing GPS signal over Middle-East
Andhra Pradesh government to begin comprehensive caste census on December 9
Uttarkashi tunnel collapse LIVE: Rescue ops enter day 14, switch to manual drilling being considered
Shocking: Week-old baby found dead with throat slit in Gurugram
PM asks top officials to expedite process of Madiga community sub-categorisation in quota: Sources
‘Our CM will be from backward community’: Amit Shah if BJP wins Telangana | Exclusive
Caste, religious politics not healthy sign for democracy: Sachin Pilot on PM Modi’s Gujjar community
Rajasthan Election: CM Gehlot shares Sachin Pilot’s video after PM Modi’s remark
Telangana Assembly Election 2023: Complete candidate list of BRS
Madhya Pradesh Election: FIR against 17 for sharing voting booth photos on social media
Indian-origin yoga prodigy Ishwar Sharma wins gold at European Yoga Sports Championship
Israel-Hamas War Day 49: Truce begins as 25 hostages released amid ceasefire | VIDEO
Ireland PM condemns violent protests after 34 arrested following knife attack in Dublin
Pakistan President Arif Alvi makes U-turn after proposing controversial solution on Palestine issue
Israel-Hamas War, Day 49: Four-day truce kicks off, first batch of hostages to be released today
‘Get a room’: Kamya Panjabi slams Isha Malviya-Samarth Jurel for getting cozy in Bigg Boss 17
Viral: Karisma Kapoor cannot stop CRYING at Indian Idol performance dedicated to Raj Kapoor
WATCH: Tiffany Haddish gets arrested in Beverly Hills | 5 points
Shershaah to Dangal: 7 Bollywood films based on real-life stories
Amitabh Bachchan’s Mumbai Bungalow ‘Jalsa’ was gifted to the megastar by THIS Indian producer
India TV Sports Wrap on November 25: Today’s top 10 trending news stories
Ravi Ashwin, Ajinkya Rahane might travel to South Africa early for first-class games
How many times a captain has been traded before a new IPL season?
Hardik Pandya back to Mumbai Indians? Speculations take internet by storm ahead of IPL 2024 auction
Suryakumar Yadav eyes major milestone during second T20I match against Australia
This new WhatsApp feature will show your profile information in chats – Deets here
Missed key moments due to JioCinema glitch in India-Australia T20 match? Fix it now
Elon Musk applauds user for using AI chatbot Grok to decrypt his tweet
Is 3-day work week possible with AI? Bill Gates replies
Is Google Pay charging convenience fees on mobile recharges? Here’s all you need to know
Explained | Why does Maldives President Mohamed Muizzu want Indian security personnel out?
Explained | What is China’s stance on Israel-Palestine conflict and what does it want?
Israel, Hamas agree to temporary ceasefire in exchange for 50 hostages. What does it mean?
Explained: What is National Herald case in which ED has attached properties worth Rs 752 crore
What is Halal Certification? Know complete controversy around it | EXPLAINED
Horoscope Today, November 25: Excellent married life for Gemini; know about other zodiac signs
Horoscope Today, November 24: Virgos to feel energetic; know about other zodiac signs
Horoscope Today, November 23: Happiness in married life for Gemini; know about other zodiac signs
Horoscope Today, November 22: Gemini needs to take care of work; know about other zodiac signs
Horoscope Today, November 21: Capricorn needs to take care of health; know about other zodiac signs
Pomegranate to Beetroot: 5 foods to increase hemoglobin levels naturally
Know about Cranberry tea side-effects and benefits
Mysterious pneumonia outbreak: India prepared for any kind of exigency, says govt | Key points
Prostate Cancer Awareness Month 2023: Why it is more common in men who live in urban areas
Pregnancy after 40 safe? Experts share considerations and 5 potential risks
China allows visa-free entry to THESE travelers | 5 points
Soya to Jackfruit: 5 Food items that taste exactly like meat
Shaadi Mubarak! 7 budget-friendly wedding venues near Delhi-NCR
5 reasons why relationships don’t last these days, reveals celebrity matchmaker
Denim Decoded: Fashion tips to rock the office in effortless work-approved jeans